Landowner questions ODFW wolf investigations
The Union County, Ore., landowner who recently discovered two of his llamas killed in a forested pasture near Five Points Creek is confident wolves are to blame for their deaths.
Howard Cantrell, a fifth-generation retired rancher, believes the Oregon Department of Fish & Wildlife erred when investigators stopped short of ruling either incident a confirmed wolf kill, based on evidence including trail camera photos of wolves in the area.
“It’s very frustrating,” Cantrell said. “People in northeast Oregon, they’re getting tired of all this stuff getting shoved under the table.”
Cantrell, whose property is about 12 miles west of La Grande, began rescuing llamas in 2006. He now owns 13 llamas, along with three horses, six goats and 25 chickens.
The first dead llama, named Sabra, was found dead Nov. 13 on a slope above Cantrell’s house. ODFW arrived the next day to investigate, reporting that most of the carcass was consumed except for the neck, head and shoulder. There was no sign of a chase or struggle, and without further evidence the death was ruled a “possible/unknown” attack.
After that, Cantrell said he began checking on his llamas every day. A second llama, Chrisy, was found dead Nov. 24 approximately 150 yards from the house, and ODFW again came the next day. This time, investigators found much more evidence of a predator attack including bite marks and at least two sets of wolf tracks in the mud on a road about 20 yards away, which appeared to be a day or two old.
Wolves were also spotted in several photos taken from a trail camera mounted 300 yards from where the carcass was found. But according to ODFW, the wounds were not consistent with extensive wolf-caused injuries and the death was ruled a “probable” wolf attack.
“There was sufficient evidence to confirm predation on the llama by a large predator, but not enough evidence to confirm which predator,” the investigation report states.
Michelle Dennehy, ODFW spokeswoman, said the injuries were “somewhat atypical” from what is usually seen in wolf depredation. She said the agency has investigated more than 300 potential wolf-livestock conflicts, and uses an evidence-based process to arrive at a conclusion.
The “probable” ruling still means Cantrell is eligible for compensation, Dennehy added. But Cantrell said he just wants to ensure ODFW is being truthful to the public.
“I’m not going to let this lie,” he said. “I want them to tell it like it is.”
On Friday, the Oregon Fish and Wildlife Commission met in Salem to begin its revision of the state’s Wolf Conservation and Management Plan. Representatives of livestock, hunting and conservation groups were on hand, though public testimony won’t be taken on the plan until the commission meets again Jan. 19.
In the meantime, Cantrell said he has moved his llamas from the pasture and into a 10-acre pen closer to the house. Wolf attacks on llamas are not unheard of in Oregon — ODFW did confirm members of the Shamrock pack killed a llama last year in Wallowa County.