Fight continues over Boardman mega-dairy
BOARDMAN, Ore. — Opponents of a 30,000-cow dairy farm in Morrow County are pressuring state regulators to change their minds on a recently approved water pollution permit for the facility, or risk taking the matter to court.
A coalition of groups has filed what’s known as a petition for reconsideration, asking the Oregon Department of Agriculture and Department of Environmental Quality to take a closer look at Lost Valley Farm and either tighten protections or reject the dairy outright.
Members of the coalition include the Animal Legal Defense Fund, Center for Biological Diversity, Center for Food Safety, Columbia Riverkeeper, Food & Water Watch, Friends of Family Farmers, Oregon Physicians for Social Responsibility, Humane Oregon and Oregon Rural Action.
Lost Valley Farm received its confined animal feeding operation permit on March 31. At the time, ODA and DEQ claimed they had crafted “the most protective of any (CAFO) permit issued to date,” requiring 11 groundwater monitoring wells on site — seven more than usual — and a minimum of three annual inspections, versus one every 10 months.
The permit became effective on April 20, and a spokeswoman for Lost Valley said the dairy is now up and running at the former Boardman Tree Farm. There are currently 16,000 animals at the farm, with about 8,700 being milking cows.
Regulators anticipate Lost Valley will build up its herd to a full 30,000 cows over the next three years, making it the second-largest dairy in Oregon. Only Threemile Canyon Farms is larger, with 70,000 head of cattle just 25 miles away in Morrow County.
Part of the CAFO permit outlines how Lost Valley will manage an estimated 187 million gallons of wastewater and manure produced each year. And though the agencies responded to 4,200 public comments about the project, opponents remain deeply concerned about potential contamination of surface water and groundwater.
“This mega-dairy threatens to spew mega pollution, creating an environmental nightmare for the people and wildlife unlucky enough to share the landscape,” said Hannah Connor, senior attorney with the Center for Biological Diversity.
Lost Valley Farm is located within the Lower Umatilla Basin Groundwater Management Area, which was designated in 1990 due to elevated levels of groundwater nitrates. Opponents say adding another large dairy in the area poses significant health risks from further groundwater contamination.
None of the petitioners have had the chance to review Lost Valley’s revised Animal Waste Management Plan, according to the petition, which lays out how the dairy will collect wastewater and use it to irrigate feed crops. Connor said the groups also want to see a plan that takes into account not only nitrogen and phosphorous from manure, but harmful antibiotic residue and pesticides.
“We really believe the agencies have some significant changes they can make here,” Connor said.
ODA and DEQ have 60 days to reply to the petition, or the groups say they will likely file an appeal. Connor said there is no indication yet their concerns will be fixed.
Wym Matthews, CAFO program manager for the Department of Agriculture, could not be reached Thursday for comment.
Greg te Velde, owner of Lost Valley Farm, defended the operation’s management practices and said he is confident the coalition’s challenge is without merit. Te Velde has been milking cows in the area since 2002, having previously established Willow Creek Dairy on land leased from Threemile Canyon Farms.
“We have worked in Oregon for over 15 years, and have consistently met the state’s high standards,” te Velde said. “Our operation at Lost Valley Farm includes protection for water quality that go further than any other dairy authorized by Oregon’s CAFO program, and has been closely vetted by state regulators.
Tarah Heinzen, staff attorney for Food & Water Watch, described the petition for reconsideration as one step below a formal appeal of the CAFO permit. The petition also asks agencies to stay Lost Valley’s permit, though Heinzen admits that is unlikely to happen.
While Heinzen said the permitting agencies did make some improvements between the draft and final permit for Lost Valley it falls well short of what is required to protect waterways. Approval of Lost Valley could also set a dangerous precedent for Oregon dairies moving forward, she added.
“We think this is a very important test case for the state to take a very close look at the potential environmental impacts of a facility this size,” Heinzen said.